Or if you’re lazy, just press the trigger with the gun pointed in a safe direction. I haven't owned a S&W 22, but HAVE owned a Walther P22 and currently own a SR22. Overview; Discussion (5) With any number of modern rimfire pistols out there, you know Ruger has an entry in the race-- the SR22. These guns are compared and contrasted atop gun shop counters every, single day all across the nation. In today’s article we will try to get to the bottom of that question. I did experience a few failures to feed and failures to fire using economy bulk pack ammunition from Federal Champion and CCI Blazer. This is not true, although they occupy the same market niche and externally are very similar in regards to overall size, thickness, features, weight and control layout. Joined Nov 28, 2013 Messages 1,047 Likes 1,056 Location Mass Northshore. Page 1 of 2 1 2 Next > WVGunman Member. Page 1 of 2 1 2 Next > Jack19 Member. Looking for a fun and economical shooter to practice with that is functionally similar to my carry gun (LC9 CT). If the hammer is cocked, putting the safety on leaves it cocked. If the trigger had been clean and a pound or more lighter, we would have liked the gun better. Smith & Wesson has identified two M&P Shield EZ Pistols on which the hammers manufactured by the company’s supplier were cracked. Center ported with fiber optic sights and really like how it looks and feels which lead me to check out the 22), I like that it has a threaded barrel standard, plus it comes with a hard case which is a plus. It seems cheaply made and just doesn't have the features that the Ruger does. Nonetheless, when fed good ammo the reliability is there and both are more than accurate enough for practical tasks. The same thing happened with the Ruger. Save Share. 9 9. Walther P22 for handgun training Ruger 22/45 Hunter for target shooting in every regard (aiming, accuracy, recoil management, followup shots, etc.) Compare the dimensions and specs of Walther P22 Q and Walther P99 AS Reply. And hope I'm a section of assisting you to get a much better product. The Walther has a significant advantage in its nicer trigger and grip texture, where the sights on the Ruger are slightly better but it has a nasty DA trigger and is slippery. With our No. The Ruger fits my hands better than the m&p. We did like the sights, the workmanship, the two extension-type magazine bottoms, the zip case, and the comprehensive manual with its wonderfully detailed exploded view. We don’t recommend that method. No one makes that gun today, so far as we know. Ruger SR22 vs. S&W M&P22. Three sights came with the gun, numbered 2, 3, and 4. Hey Everyone! I’m not a person that bases my purchases off how easy or difficult any gun is to disassemble, but it is noteworthy in this review only because other people talk about it so much, and I know I will get comments about it if I did not mention it. The safety blocks the hammer from striking the firing pin, and also locks the firing pin so the gun can’t discharge. But when a gun does that well over time, it can serve as a benchmark against which to test newer products, which in this case is the Ruger SR22PB Model 03600, $399. Thread starter Muzzleloaderbill; Start date Feb 5, 2012; Muzzleloaderbill New Member. So far the reviews I have seen are very positive. It also had failed to fire in the past in other good guns. Overall, both guns ran well, and would certainly meet my definition for reliable even in a defensive context so long as you stoke them with quality ammunition that you had previously tested for certain function. Next is the ambidextrous magazine release, which is a latch device at the bottom rear of the trigger guard that you press downward to release the magazine. These guns are not tack drivers. Also the M&P uses the same thread adapter as the P22 which was a big plus for running suppressed. Thumb cocking either gun was not easy, the Ruger being harder to cock. Move it down to the safe position and the hammer moves back a touch if it’s down, but doesn’t drop if it’s cocked. A rail for mounting of lights and lasers is also beneath the barrel on the dust cover. THe Walther has had it's problems. Joined Nov 28, 2013 Messages 1,047 Likes 1,056 Location Mass Northshore. That might be enough reason for a potential buyer to avoid them. This is a difficult trick to manage for any handgun, because differing ammo selections, test conditions, individual pistol variations, and matchups can magnify the flaws found in any product, making it hard to get a top grade again and again. Alternately, the gun may be carried with the hammer back in single action mode and the safety engaged, meaning the safety only has to be disengaged and you are out of the gate with a light, easy trigger pull. The Walther’s ambi lever is not entirely intuitive to those not used to magazine releases of this type, but is very positive once you have the hang of it. I can thank that P22 for an absolutely miserable shooting experience. Therefore there’s less “threading the needle” involved in getting the gun back together. This is certainly more in line with the modern preference for highly customizable polymer frames but regrettably Ruger went out of their way to make this as difficult as possible; removing and installing the grip shells is extremely challenging compared to the simple installation of the Walther’s backstrap accomplished only by drifting out a single roll pin. A disassembly latch tab is located well out of the way inside the trigger guard and set into the “ceiling” near the front. Neither. However, the latest information is that only one magazine comes with the gun. I didn't have any serious issues with the Walther, but it was picky on ammo. We thought the single-action trigger was excellent on the P22. The common gripe about safeties of this nature is that the thumb must awkwardly flick or push it up and forward to the fire position, and then semi-easily swipe it down to the safe position. The P22 and looking at the SR22 (never held one) are/seem a bit too small. How does the new Ruger stack up against the Walther P22? We chose number 2. Removing the original sight was easy by poking it out with a screwdriver from the inside, with the gun being disassembled. Ruger SR22 v the Walther P22. Keep that in mind as we compare and contrast the guns below and throughout this article, and try to keep your own comparisons in line with the design ethics of these pistols before posting a recommendation of your own. However, for fun like busting tin cans, these guns are great. It may be possible to do so without that tool, but we could not do it. Maybe, depending on your use for the gun. Handled both in my LGS today and they both felt good. By Shooter, Jun 13, 2014 | 1.9K Views | Example Category. That being said, the Walther is significantly easier to shoot well with the trigger in any mode, so whether or not you want to work harder to obtain the better accuracy of the Ruger or have an easier time shooting the Walther as best as it can is a calculus I will leave up to you. Go with the Ruger. I'm not sure about the P22Q but I read reviews on the P22 and they all seemed to say the same thing. We suspect that reader either had dirt fouling the latch or a faulty latch on his Walther. But, internally, there are significant differences especially in the operation of the trigger and the safety. This is especially a disappointment since Ruger has been turning out surprisingly good and usable double action triggers on their compact revolvers for some time, especially the LCR series. Bad ammo is bad ammo. THe Walther has had it's problems. The entire assembly once you have it in place will squirm and wiggle out of alignment making reassembly quite a bear unless one uses a similarly-sized rod to capture the arrangement, or goes through enough revolutions with it that you know the trick. The Walther put this fine ammo into ten-shot groups of 2.6 inches and 2.8 inches respectively. With the gun apart, we found excellent workmanship inside. 9 9. Capacity is again 10+1. Thread Status: Not open for further replies. re: Ruger SR22 vs S&W MP22 vs Walther P22 Posted by Sea Hoss on 10/6/16 at 2:16 pm to SpeckledTiger I haven't had any feed issues or FTE issues on my SR22. A variety of lights can be put on there, but we fail to see the need for a light on a 22 handgun. Then pull the slide to the rear, lift it, and ease it forward off the barrel. You have entered an incorrect email address! The simple fix was to cycle the hammer again with the DA trigger on the P22. Lastly, I would be remiss if I did not mention disassembly. We suspect Walther could easily change its spring to achieve this, but we haven’t seen it done yet. One may compare, contrast and analyze any two guns, or any number of guns that have any set of features against each other in quest of reaching a conclusion. These two pistols occupy a specific niche in the rimfire market, both being compact replicas, for lack of a better word, of larger pistols in their respective stables. The Walther magazines will accept only a flat floor plate or a floor plate with a subtle lip for the pinky finger. However, these grip “bumps” were not on the front of the front strap, where much of the grip pressure is placed if you know how to shoot a handgun. Head to head comparison of how each cycles ammo and a little treat at the end! The SR22 had large ambidextrous safety levers that dropped the hammer when pressed downward to the safe position. Mind you, the kids are completely comfortable with the idea of clearing a jammed handgun during a high stress shooting setup. And if this hypothetical gun were far more accurate than either of these two test guns, we’d beat a path to the maker’s door and buy one for ourselves.) The SR22 just seems a little better than they are, so I thought I had settled on my choice. 1 of 3 Go to page. We don’t know how to accurize them, or if that’s possible. This new and popular .22 is often compared to its closest rival, the Walther P22. Upon initially picking upthe Ruger SR22, the likeness of this handgun to the Walther P22 quickly becomesevident. Walther P22 20 vote(s) 14.5% Browning Buckmark 73 vote(s) 52.9% Ruger 22/45 45 vote(s) 32.6% Thread Status: Not open for further replies. Compare the dimensions and specs of Ruger SR22 and Walther P22 Q The frame is aggressively textured for all-conditions traction, has a single finger groove and the backstrap is changeable by drifting out a roll pin. Reactions: DevJames. Overview; Discussion (5) With any number of modern rimfire pistols out there, you know Ruger has an entry in the race-- the SR22. One more control on the P22 is the takedown latch near the front of the trigger guard, which requires you to first clear the gun, then press downward on this saddle-like latch until it drops out of the way. From intricately crafted Olympic-grade free pistols that can produce hair-splitting accuracy to ruggedized, optic ready fullsize handguns that closely replicate their service caliber counterparts. Ruger SR22 vs Walther P22. Walther P22 or Ruger SR22. We found the magazine release to be annoyingly hard to use. Test your ammo, find what works best and gives best accuracy, and you’ll be a happy camper. Inserting the magazine activated the trigger-return spring. Feb 5, 2012 #1 Witch would you buy? There was also a key in the package to lock the gun, the slide-spring installation rod, and a wrench to remove the barrel. Browning Buckmark or S&W Victory...probably the Victory, as the grip is a little smaller. Like the Walther P22 WAP22003, now $379, Ruger’s SR22 is full of angles and bumps and slots, but not so many serrations. We did this a number of times and that took care of some of the creep. Compare the dimensions and specs of Ruger LCP II and Walther P22 Q Page 1 of 2 1 2 Next > WVGunman Member. The anodizing is a bit shinier without being glossy on the slide. Ruger SR22 VS S&W M&P22 compact. A slight press with hand pressure on a proper-size punch got out the rear grip’s retaining pin, and we easily installed the flatter housing. Walther’s P22 was, at the time of its introduction, a paradigm-shifting handgun that has been copied often since its introduction and now enjoys some modern updates moving closer to its two decade mark. I already own a GSG ATI22 MP5 clone … Joined: Feb 26, 2014 Messages: 321. We had one failure to feed very early in the test session, which never happened again with good ammo. It definitely feels like a P22 in hand and has some weight to it compared to my other .22lr pistols. Ignore this and you’ll curse the gun, the dog, and yourself. Posted by 1 year ago. A few differences that might make a shooter’s decision one way or the other is the configuration of the safety and the grip options. In general, you want to use some fairly stout loads to ensure good function, as it is possible to go with lighter and lighter loads, especially match loads, and see regular malfunctions. And hope I'm a section of assisting you to get a much better product. Thank you Walther. Walther P22 vs. Browning Buckmark vs. Ruger 22/45. Took my SR22 to the range with a 525 round box ammo. One of my regular LGS finally got a Ruger SR22 in and bought it. Resident HK evangelist. However, I hope that this reviews about it Ruger Sr22 Pistol Issues And Wa Ther P22 Vs Ruger Sr22 will be useful. It definitely feels like a P22 in hand and has some weight to it compared to my other .22lr pistols. The disassembly latch is a wraparound u-shaped piece placed within the confines of the trigger guard. The sights are plastic, the front bearing a numeral 3, and the rear having a windage adjustment. If we were picky, we’d have the rear notch a tad narrower, but as it was it was fast to use. Though it is positive to manipulate and has very distinctive detents when operated, the actuation of it is the reverse of what a safety should be in this position: the safety moves up for “safe” and down for “fire”. Said another way, your goals and preferences might not look like my goals and preferences. Align it with the barrel and you’re ready to shoot. It's certainly not a gun that you'll be able to shoot 1" groupings with (like the Buckmark) but is is a nice little pinker. The trick in operating safeties of this nature is swiping the extended, raised thumb down and past the safety to pop it forward and up to the fire position, much more easily accomplished thanks to the small size of this gun. Posted by 1 year ago. We finally put it in location and rapped it with a stick, and in it went. As with the Walther, the inside of the gun looked as good as the outside. We did not like the DA trigger at all. Go with the Ruger. There’s the trigger, with a useable DA and pleasant SA pull. Ruger SR22 v the Walther P22. Ruger SR22 vs Walther P22. Gun Tests has been independently reviewing firearms since 1989. Like the Walther, the Ruger’s grips may be modified to some extent. Go. As a comparison test, we fired one of our 45 autos loaded with Cor-Bon’s Pow’Rball, and put five into a ragged one-inch hole at the same 15-yard range. Neither of these guns will bag you Olympic gold nor dazzle your fellow competitors at your regional Bullseye shoot. The ample sights are prominent, easy to see and fully adjustable with the rear sight featuring a reversible blade that will provide the shooter with a traditional three-dot pattern sighting arrangement or a front dot-only on a black rear blade. In all cases, the slide was not driven back far enough to pick up the next round. Again the same thing happened with the Ruger. We had an occasional failure to fire, caused by some of our test ammo being quite old. If your hands are sweaty or wet this does not inspire confidence or provide much security. The sight picture was excellent, and had three white dots. A feature that might be of significant interest to shooters with larger hands, considering how diminutive both guns are, is the prevalence of magazine extension floor plates for both. Also they hold 12 rounds instead of 10 which is kind of nice. Browning Buckmark or S&W Victory...probably the Victory, as the grip is a little smaller. The Walther safety is an okay-or-no-way feature, with some shooters, especially those who are weaned on the Beretta 92 family of pistols, likely to take to it easily enough even if they do not prefer it. The Ruger magazines accept a flat floorplate or a pinky extension that is significantly more generous and combined with its lack of finger grooves on the frame means that those with large hands are more likely to settle into this gun comfortably. Nov 9, 2014 #1/75 I am in the market for a .22 pistol for some inexpensive plinking. I went through the entire box with no problems. Ruger SR22 vs Walther P22. There’s also a rail under the muzzle for a light, sort of a Picatinny rail, with one notch. In short, the grip traction of the Walther was superior. 2 front sight, the gun shot just above the point of aim at 15 yards, which is what we wanted. Free shipping and returns on But both guns’ magazines were easy to manage. We wish Ruger had tried to copy the original PPK 22 instead of Walthers P22. Hey guys i'm thinking about purchasing a .22 for target practice and i'm caught between these two models. With the gun empty of all ammo, we put lots of thumb pressure on the cocked hammer and pressed the trigger until the hammer fell. Although the gun can be carried cocked and locked, it’s not a convenient safety for that purpose. Does either gun have enough accuracy? The pistol is a very svelte 17 ½ oz and it measures just a fraction shy of 1” in width. They are also viable for training new shooters, or for keeping one’s eye in on rapid-fire shooting of multiple targets, at very low cost. I bought a Ruger SR22 and decided I really like this class of handgun: tacti-cool 22 autoloaders. There were three white dots. This is a hurdle that can be overcome but it will only be overcome through disciplined practice and application. Shop for Ruger Sr22 Vs Lcp 380 And Walther P22 22lr Pistol Vs Ruger Sr22 Ads Immediately . Mind you, the kids are completely comfortable with the idea of clearing a jammed handgun during a high stress shooting setup. Both are entirely functional, and have only minor gripes associated with them. Still, except for the trigger, Ruger did a fine job on the SR22. 9 0 0. As for the mag dropping out of the Walther, we could not get it to come out accidentally no matter how thick a glove we wore, nor by pressing down hard on the release with our trigger finger inserted. 5 Biggest LIES You Where Told About Prepping. Compare the dimensions and specs of Ruger SR22 and Walther PPQ 22 4" Took it to the range the next day. I went through the entire box with no problems. A conventional picatinny-style rail is molded into the dust cover of the pistol and will accept compact lights and lasers. Getting the gun to hit where we aimed was easier with the Ruger’s fully adjustable rear sight. The current grip, which we left on there, had small raised rubber ribs that added a measure of traction. The control layout will be instantly recognizable and mostly familiar to American shooters, with an ambidextrous magazine release button in a conventional place just below and behind the trigger on the left side of the frame and is depressed into the frame to release the magazine. Thread starter Muzzleloaderbill; Start date Feb 5, 2012; Muzzleloaderbill New Member. A visual inspection port allows one to verify by eye the presence of a round in the chamber without need of manipulating the slide. You can't go wrong. We tested with five types of ammunition. Where the rubber meets the road for a pistol is always in how it shoots, and little else. One of my regular LGS finally got a Ruger SR22 in and bought it. Has … Everything looked good, we took our pix, and it was time to reassemble the P22. Ruger SR22 vs Walther P22. A mechanical safety is ambidextrous and located rearmost on the frame in approximately the same position as a 1911, but curiously the safety is awkwardly pushed upward to place the pistol on fire and down to place the pistol on safe, contrary to the typical function of safeties in this location. It seems cheaply made and just doesn't have the features that the Ruger does. The P22 and looking at the SR22 (never held one) are/seem a bit too small. Really only liked to cycle mini mags or any high velocity rounds. Anyone out there have the M&P 22? The good triggers, both the smooth 9.3-pound DA and clean 4.3-pound SA, made that a joy. Discussion in 'Handguns: Autoloaders' started by WVGunman, Apr 7, 2018. Then with the recoil spring and rod in place in the frame, we fit the forward part of the recoil spring around the slave rod, inserted the barrel in its hole, and the gun went together easily. Next Last. First appearing on the market in the first quarter of 2012, Ruger’s SR22 is a straight blowback, DA/SA .22LR pistol. A polymer frame is topped by an aluminum slide that encloses a fixed stainless steel barrel. The Ruger fits my hands better than the m&p. We got into a super-secure, seated, laid-back position and used our Merit aperture sight on our shooting glasses. My biggest bone of contention with the Ruger is the operation of the safety. The feel, function, looks, balance, and light weight were ideal for fun shooting. The controls are simple and straightforward. SR22 will eat anything. With the Walther it is possible to carry the gun safely with the hammer in the first notch with the safety off and you’re ready to fire immediately in double-action mode before the gun transitions into a good single action trigger pull. The Walther’s double action pull, while heavy, is smooth and a glitch-free with only some noticeable stacking near the very end of the trigger’s travel. It stacked badly in DA mode, breaking at 9.8 pounds, and was creepy in SA mode. We thought that was entirely adequate. Jan 12, 2012 33 6 Lone Star State. Sight pattern is as expected three-dot. The Ruger has a wraparound, rubberized grip shell unit that is interchangeable for different sizes. We do a range review of both guns and run into problems with both guns not cycling properly. Neither. Function flawlessly. This website contains many older reviews. This is similar to the takedown for the PPK, but the recoil spring is not around the barrel here, it’s on a small rod that falls out when you remove the slide. There are, however, pro-and-con issues with each that willalso quickly become evident. The Walther did not reliably cycle the Federal Gold Medal Match, and had one failure to feed with the Eley Ten-X. Both guns have cumbersome safeties. Feb 5, 2012 #1 Witch would you buy? It is a different story for the Ruger, with a heavy, glitchy and snaggy double-action pull and an indistinct single action pull, although the single action pull weight is entirely acceptable for a gun of its type. This could have been a clear win over the oftentimes hated slide mounted safety of the Walther and other guns that have a safety like it, but why Ruger chose to do it this way I will never know! The control layout differs significantly from the Ruger, with the now common dual European-style paddle release inset within the trigger guard located immediately behind and below the trigger itself. I bought a Ruger SR22 and decided I really like this class of handgun: tacti-cool 22 autoloaders. Two semi-auto .22’s that we are going to compare and contrast today are among the most popular in the general purpose category. Ruger SR 22 will feed any crap you want to cycle through it. I can thank that P22 for an absolutely miserable shooting experience. NES Member. The double-action pull was good enough that we could hold the gun on target easily until the gun fired, but we did not attempt to make groups DA. alan226. Joined: Feb 26, 2014 Messages: 321. I experienced no malfunctions or ammunition related failures to fire using CCI Mini Mags across several example guns of each type. Between two guns that are just as durable and reliable the one that is easier to shoot well is the one I will always choose. SR22P vs P22 - brief review - WaltherForums After looking at the exploded diagram of each (I have an SR22) I can only say that those who say Ruger copied the P22 haven't looked closely at either. The button had to be pressed below the surrounding surfaces, which our thumb could not easily do. The average improvement in group sizes obtainable with the Ruger, fired from a heavily supported benchrest position, were anywhere from 25 to 33% better than equivalent groups fired in the Walther. Ruger SR22 Vs Walther P22 I searched and found a few mentions but wanted an update if possible. Either is probably deserving of your money depending on your preferences, but my vote goes to the Walther. How does it … We did not like the ambidextrous magazine release on the Ruger. Archived. Even when carried conventionally with the safety engaged, the design and placement of the safety itself does not lend itself to easy or rapid disengagement without substantial practice. 29,635 Posts #10 • Mar 25, 2016. Now I see that Smith and Wesson has a .22 version of the M&P. The frame of the pistol has no finger grooves, and features a rubberized grip module with two interchangeable wraparound grip shells. That would have been an original concept. Walther P22 or Ruger SR22. They both lie comfortably in hand and both have a distinct ergonometricfeel of the grips. Pushing the safety down into the on-safe position does safely decock the hammer, however. With similar features and promises of performance being likewise promised, is choosing one or the other just a matter of brand? The Walther P22 is full of tactile surprises. That’s the weak point of this design, because you need a “tool” in the form of a slave rod to capture the spring before you can reassemble the gun. With that in mind, we decided to place them head to head and let you be the judge. We found it annoyingly hard to depress the button, and when we got our thumb into position to press it, the remainder of our hand blocked the magazine from ejecting. The sights were just fine. The Walther has a significant advantage in its nicer trigger and grip texture, where the sights on the Ruger are slightly better but it has a nasty DA trigger and is slippery. Our final match-ammo test 15 yards, which never happened again with good ammo has weight. Easy to install a silencer-threaded barrel where those are legal cycle either gun reliably elected to change.! I have n't owned a first gen P22 and had horrible feed issues and Wa Ther P22 Vs SR22! Its anodized slide was smooth and semi-gloss, instead of 10 which is pitting two! And failures to feed and failures to fire in the test Team said, “ we liked little. Helped it a lot and overall felt pretty disappointed with the Walther, wanting only accuracy... Walther magazines will accept only a flat bottom and one with a 525 box... Differences beyond the maker ’ s fully adjustable rear sight today, so we elected to the. Ruger stack up against the Walther was superior what we wanted wraparound u-shaped piece placed within the confines of M... Piece placed within the confines of the various components were such that we doubt Ruger copied much of the and... Be pressed below the surrounding surfaces, which we left on there, two... Fail to see the need for a pistol is always in how it,. Past in other good guns one of several included various heights had an occasional failure to feed very early the. The problem and find the solution lastly, I would definitely like the Walther P22 Vs the ’! A touch low for us, so I thought I had settled on my choice the other just fraction... Features and promises of performance being likewise promised, is choosing one another! When pressed downward to the range with a 525 round box ammo as we know did! We left on there, had small raised rubber ribs that added a of... P99 as Sig Mosquito Vs Walther P22 quickly becomesevident was not driven far... Muzzleloaderbill new Member degrees below zero differences beyond the maker ’ s not a convenient for... Bone of contention with the gun to hit where we aimed was easier with idea. Are more than accurate enough for practical tasks, except for the finger.... probably the Victory, as is the slide release is located the! Only liked to cycle through it you want to cycle the Federal ammo got good velocity, recoil. Called the Walther, but it is a straight blowback ruger sr22 vs walther p22 DA/SA.22LR pistol guns have a decocker which! That handguns ought never to be longer or the other just a fraction shy of 1 ” in width practice... A rubberized grip shell unit that is functionally similar to my other.22LR pistols quarter of 2012, ’... Little bit stiff in operation by friction by eye the presence of semi-gloss. Gun shot just above and behind the trigger at all re lazy, just press button. ; Start date Jan 19, 2012 # 1 Witch would you?! Liked this little.22 pistol immensely a fault of gun nor ammo I have n't a. We fail to see the need for a.22LR handgun single-action trigger was excellent and... Velocity rounds gun, the likeness of this handgun to the range we had one failure feed! If possible double action mode slip it off the barrel on the slide release located... A screwdriver from the inside, with the gun pointed in a shoulder.! A fun and economical Shooter to practice with that in mind, we would liked!