The lawsuit … November 30, 2019 — A Hyundai panoramic sunroof settlement is final after a federal judge overruled objections to the settlement agreement filed … If you continue to use this site, you consent to this use of cookies. WATCH: An increasing number of drivers has been calling for an investigation into exploding sunroofs, Tony Tighe reports. No mandatory recalls have been issued. The judge says the $200 is meant to compensate a person who was "scared" by the breaking glass. Front ¾ vehicle photos © 1986-2018 Autodata, Inc. dba Chrome Data. However, the judge didn't see things the same way. CarComplaints.com ® is an online automotive complaint resource that uses graphs to show automotive defect patterns, based on complaint data submitted by visitors to the site. Front ¾ vehicle photos © 1986-2018 Autodata, Inc. dba Chrome Data. Windshields (in the usa) are laminated layers of glass and stretchy plastic. The cause of the exploding sunroof Both lawsuits explain that the sunroof is made of tempered glass that includes multiple layers. Following the 2017 investigation into exploding sunroofs on cars, Consumer Reports shares details on exploding sunroof court cases and the latest data on this car safety issue. “I thought I got rear ended. When you're driving down the road you probably wouldn't expect it to start raining glass. In December 2019, five automakers announced recalls of older model cars because of a separate issue with Takata airbags. Toyota is recalling about 9,500 model year 2019-2020 RAV4s and RAV4 Hybrids. Hyundai has been steadfast in their refusal to acknowledge any sort of defect, but a 2019 lawsuit settlement gives owners the coverage they need in case it does happen. California consumers may exercise their CCPA rights here. And if a sunroof shattered and the customer was scared by the experience, Hyundai will pay the owner $200. We were driving on US-20 in eastern Oregon yesterday in our 2015 Outback 3.6R - it's the middle of nowhere, and there were no other vehicles around and our sunroof exploded. Exploding/Shattered Panoramic Sunroof-2019 Ram 1500 Limited Thread starter rsan11; Start date Aug 5, 2020; Prev. That's exactly what happened to an Ogden man. Have a car complaint to add? Example: "Bad Brakes", "Toyota Recall", etc. Additionally, the judge overruled that customers should be compensated for the time spent making sunroof repairs. Mercedes Sunroof Recall and Other Legal Actions The June 2020 class action isn’t the first legal action the carmaker has faced for defective sunroofs. Exploding/Shattered Panoramic Sunroof-2019 Ram 1500 Limited Thread starter rsan11; Start date Aug 5, 2020; rsan11 New Member. are trademarks of Autobeef LLC, All rights reserved. All the other windows are tempered (heat-treated) glass. We use cookies to analyze & improve your experience, & to personalize content and ads. Consumer complaints about exploding sunroofs have spiked in recent years. I wouldn’t be surprised if this becomes a recall. Spontaneous Sunroof Breakage . Reports on sunroof glass explosions highlight possible risks. California consumers may exercise their CCPA rights here. "CarComplaints.com" ®, "Autobeef", "What's Wrong With YOUR Car?" The plaintiffs claim even when the vehicles are still under warranties, Volkswagen refuses to cover the expenses and throws the cost back onto the customer. Jody Winder was walking back from an errand in Milton, Ont., on a mild fall day in 2017, when she discovered a hole in the panoramic sunroof of her brand-new BMW X5. The complaints are organized into groups with data published by vehicle, vehicle component, and specific problem. Why panoramic sunroofs can explode and how much it costs to fix RELATED: Mercedes-Benz Is Issuing a Recall to Fix a Previous Recall While the science behind these sunroofs is complicated, the lawsuit said that it all comes down to the manufacturing and assembly process of … The Hyundai panoramic sunroof settlement provides customers with an extended warranty and reimbursements for previous repairs paid by customers. Understandably, this has left many concerned Ford vehicle owners impacted by exploding sunroofs worried they’ve purchased a “lemon” vehicle and looking for alternative options and remedies for the financial damages suffered as a result of repairing this defect. Joined Jun 21, 2019 Messages 3 Reaction score 2. Example: "Bad Brakes", "Toyota Recall", etc. However, the judge ruled the attorney fees are "fair" and what Hyundai owners will receive is "reasonable.". globalnews.ca The judge ruled that recall, in addition to previous Audi sunroof recalls, is enough to at least allege the automaker may have known about problems with the sunroofs. "At a hearing in November 2013 before Korea's Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, and Transport ("MOLIT"), KATRI presented its findings and allowed automakers to respond. ... Jeep had a recall on their sunroof. Certain objectors also argue Hyundai should provide trade-in compensation for customers who traded their vehicles before receiving notice of the settlement, but again, the judge overruled the claim. Automakers across the board are having problems with their sunroofs randomly exploding. A sunroof brings sunshine into a vehicle, but some ongoing safety incidents have cast clouds over the popular feature. CarComplaints.com ® is an online automotive complaint resource that uses graphs to show automotive defect patterns, based on complaint data submitted by visitors to the site. Add your complaint here, about any vehicle. Check glassBYTEs.com for continuing coverage of this suit. Hyundai denies any wrongdoing and says there are no defects associated with the sunroofs. The plaintiff is represented by the Gibbs Law Group, Tousley Brain Stephens, Greg Coleman Law, Farris Bobango, and Berger Montague. The judge also overruled the argument that Hyundai should pay $200 to a customer who wasn't in the vehicle when the sunroof shattered. If you Google "exploding sunroof", there's plenty of information. The objectors also said the extended warranty which doubles the original warranty doesn't last long enough. The new recall affects 1.4 million older German and Japanese models. Published: 5:27 PM PDT April 18, 2019. CarComplaints.com has complaints from owners of the Hyundai vehicles named in the panoramic sunroof settlement. The Takata airbags in the latest recall might fail to inflate properly in a crash, or they, too, could explode. Add your complaint here, about any vehicle. al., v. Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. Exploding sunroofs prompt calls for investigation, recall A consumer group is calling for an expanded federal investigation and recall after years of reported car sunroof explosions. Also dismissed were claims concerning unfair competition law, California Consumer Legal Remedies Act and fraud by omission after the judge concluded the lawsuit did not adequately "allege that VW had knowledge of the alleged defect at the time of sale or lease.". Saying the Hyundai panoramic sunroof settlement is "fair, reasonable, and adequate," the judge overruled objections the class action lacks merit and the compensation isn't enough for affected customers. You may have heard of spontaneously exploding panoramic sunroofs lately, as it’s more common than spontaneous windshield breakage, but it still doesn’t happen frequently. And I should call my insurance to get it fixed. Hyundai Panoramic Sunroof Class-Action Settlement ∞ We use cookies to analyze & improve your experience, & to personalize content and ads. The class action contends that despite this knowledge that its sunroofs can explode without warning, Ford has not issued a recall on any of the affected models. Hyundai issued a recall on certain 2012 model-year Velosters for spontaneously exploding panoramic sunroofs. Exploding sunroofs: Complaints are soaring – here are the car brands and models involved Transport Canada data shows spike in complaints as sunroofs keep getting bigger and more popular. For more information on how we collect and use this information, please review our Privacy Policy. My 2007 blew out last year and I found out when I took it to the shops to have a new one installed. The judge denied a motion to dismiss implied warranty claims in the first amended lawsuit but did dismiss unjust enrichment claims with prejudice. And he's not the only one. Similar lawsuits against Volkswagen, Kia, Ford, and Mercedes continue to make their way through the pipeline despite partial dismissals and attempts from automakers to toss the cases, and the parties in a class action against Nissan over exploding sunroofs agreed to mediation in January 2019. "CarComplaints.com" ®, "Autobeef", "What's Wrong With YOUR Car?" read stories from drivers who praise our work. The owner said this will cost you nothing as jeep has a recall. Joined Aug 22, 2020 Messages 122 Reaction score 34 Location Dallas Ft Worth. The plaintiffs claim these Hyundai vehicles are equipped with sunroofs that are prone to shatter and Hyundai concealed the problem from customers. For example, Giorgio Enea filed a class action for shattering sunroofs on behalf of Mercedes-Benz owners in California state court in May 2018. May 13, 2019 — A Volkswagen exploding sunroof class action lawsuit will continue for California customers after a federal judge refused to dismiss the complaint. November 30, 2019 — I went directly to the dealer because it was on my way home, they looked at it and said only the front glass is covered by warranty? Nothing hit it, no big trucks or anything ahead of me kicking up rocks, and when I pulled over the glass was angled upward like it was struck from the inside. For more information on how we collect and use this information, please review our Privacy Policy. There was no car in front of me and I was driving in an open area. read stories from drivers who praise our work. But the federal judge ruled objections to the settlement didn't warrant disapproval of the final settlement. The lawsuit alleges Volkswagen failed to warn consumers about sunroofs that spontaneously shatter due to defects in the sunroofs. My sunroof just exploded while on the freeway this evening! Plaintiffs Douglas and Kathleen Krebsbach state that they purchased a 2013 Ford Escape with a factory-installed panoramic sunroof. Hey, it’s something. Objectors argue Hyundai should buy back the vehicles instead of offer customers a simple extended warranty. Tempered glass is stronger, but it can explode if there is a problem with one of the compressed layers. Dec 8, 2020 #21 PowerJrod said: We thought we'd been shot at - if thinking you've been shot at in the middle of nowhere seems unreasonable... so is a spontaneously exploding sunroof! The plaintiffs are represented by the Law Office of Robert L. Starr, APC, and the Law Office of Stephen M. Harris, APC. Exploding sunroofs have been an issue with an alarming number of new cars, including Toyota and Honda models–and no one is exactly sure why. The Volkswagen exploding sunroof class action lawsuit was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California - Deras, et. I only have 16K miles on this thing! Reports of car sunroofs “exploding” have been popping up with greater frequency, and this can be a pretty big cause for concern because the incidents are happening in new cars. A panoramic sunroof uses thinner glass to save on weight and also improve the vehicle’s fuel economy. Front ¾ vehicle photos © 1986-2018 Autodata, Inc. dba Chrome Data. In addition, while the lawyers who filed the lawsuit will receive $5.4 million, objectors to the settlement claim Hyundai customers should receive more from the settlement than what is offered. But the plaintiffs also allege the automaker knew the sunroofs could explode because VW recalled Beetles for the problem, although Volkswagen says the recall was issued due to a very specific manufacturing defect for just those models. Sunroofs are exploding more often, says Consumer Reports. A Volkswagen exploding sunroof class action lawsuit will continue for California customers after a federal judge refused to dismiss the complaint. The VW class action lawsuit includes California customers who purchased or leased these vehicles if they were equipped with factory-installed sunroofs: According to the class action lawsuit, owners get stuck paying for sunroof repairs and replacements because the automaker blames incidents of broken glass on outside objects hitting the glass. Aug 5, 2020 #1 While I was driving from work, I heard a loud explosion that sounded like a tire blowout. The sunroofs allegedly don't need to be hit with outside objects, say the plaintiffs, and the proof is found in the angle of the broken glass which points outward. According to the lawsuit, VW knew about the dangers of exploding sunroofs because in 2012, the South Korean government's auto safety and testing arm called KATRI opened an investigation into exploding sunroofs. But the judge ruled he didn't find that argument persuasive because it's not "an unusually high number of complaints" relative to the "potentially hundreds of thousands or more" affected vehicles. The probe included multiple manufacturers and VW was allegedly updated about the results which found panoramic sunroofs were prone to shatter. Go. Volkswagen also allegedly didn't meet the engineering levels needed to install safe sunroofs in vehicles and decided to sell the vehicles without being honest with consumers. Currently the settlement hearing for Hyundai’s exploding sunroof lawsuit is scheduled for August 12, 2019. "Standing alone, the allegations of consumer complaints are therefore insufficient to allege knowledge.". Representatives from VW as well as other manufacturers were present at this meeting.". Objectors also told the judge it wasn't fair to pay $200 to customers who experienced a shattered sunroof, but not provide the same compensation to customers who will experience it in the future. Allegedly exploding sunroofs have been seen in all kinds of vehicles—Volvos, Fords, Lincolns and Nissans among others. The lawsuit says this should convince anyone the glass wasn't forced downward such as what would happen if a rock hit the sunroof from the outside. are trademarks of Autobeef LLC, All rights reserved. The Hyundai panoramic sunroof lawsuit and settlement was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California - Glenn, et al., v. Hyundai Motor America et al. N. njt07 Active Member. Have a car complaint to add? 12/29/20 My 2019 Ford Raptor stationary part of the sunroof exploded in the middle of driving on highway I-25. ... As a soon-to-be 2019 Ody owner I'm wondering if a deflector would offer any protection from the "must have been a rock, dismissed without so much as a look" treatment by the dealership? This entry was posted in glassBYTEs Original Story and tagged Billy Glenn, exploding sunroofs, Hyundai, lawsuit, NHTSA, settlement hearing. May 13, 2019 — Since 1995, regulatory agencies in the U.S. and Canada have received over 1,200 reports of sunroofs suddenly shattering without any explanation or apparent cause. Toyota recalls model year 2019-2020 RAV4s and RAV4 Hybrids Drivers could lose control of the vehicle. Front ¾ vehicle photos © 1986-2018 Autodata, Inc. dba Chrome Data. Bookmark the permalink. A Hyundai panoramic sunroof settlement is final after a federal judge overruled objections to the settlement agreement filed by certain Hyundai customers. The plaintiffs claim Volkswagen must have known about shattering sunroof dangers based on 57 complaints filed with the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). However, the judge gave the plaintiffs a chance to amend those claims and file a second amended lawsuit. The complaints are organized into groups with data published by vehicle, vehicle component, and specific problem. There are a number of lawsuits against major … If you continue to use this site, you consent to this use of cookies. Sudden explosive noise (I thought we were shot at) and then our back sunroof exploded all over the dog.” Driver of a 2013 Mini Cooper Countryman in Arizona, CarComplaints.com “Not even 20 mins off the car lot with a 2010 gen 3 IV prius, our sunroof explodes. Consumer Reports tells you what you need to know to stay safe on the road and how to avoid large repair bills. Once a feature limited mostly to luxury models, sunroofs have become more common in all … 1; 2; First Prev 2 of 2 Go to page. Not all Hyundai customers are pleased with the settlement and told the judge they didn't believe the deal was good enough for consumers. Tempered windows are designed to "explode" into tiny, low-mass blunt cubes, while the laminated windshield tries to entrap all the sharp bits in the plastic layers and remain in as few pieces as possible. Ram 1500 Limited Thread starter rsan11 ; Start date Aug 5, 2020 ; new... Those claims and file a second amended lawsuit but did dismiss unjust enrichment claims with prejudice from customers a sunroof! '', `` toyota recall '', `` toyota recall '', `` what 's Wrong with YOUR Car ''! If this becomes a recall there was no Car in front of me and found... While on the road and how to avoid large repair bills sunroof made! And told the judge ruled the attorney fees are `` fair '' and Hyundai. Spontaneously exploding panoramic sunroofs was posted in glassBYTEs Original Story and tagged Billy Glenn, exploding,... Judge did n't see things the same way the complaints are organized groups. And what Hyundai owners will receive is `` reasonable. `` of Mercedes-Benz owners in California court... First amended lawsuit but did dismiss unjust enrichment claims with prejudice a person who was `` scared exploding sunroof recall 2019... Into a vehicle, but it can explode if there is a problem with one of the sunroof in! On highway I-25 fail to inflate properly in a crash, or they, too, explode! To dismiss implied warranty claims in the U.S. District court for the Northern District of -! Scared '' by the breaking glass my insurance to get it fixed First amended but... Are equipped with sunroofs that spontaneously shatter due to defects in the sunroof... Heard a loud explosion that sounded like a tire blowout use this information, review. Down the road and how to avoid large repair bills Deras, et &., please review our Privacy Policy Takata airbags in the U.S. District court for the Northern of. Experience, & to personalize content and ads the compressed layers `` what 's Wrong with YOUR Car? settlement... S fuel economy cause of the sunroof is made of tempered glass is stronger, but it can if., 2020 ; rsan11 new Member to analyze & improve YOUR experience, & to content! Data published by vehicle, vehicle component, and Berger Montague concealed the problem from customers often, says Reports... Sunroof shattered and the customer was scared by the Gibbs Law Group, Tousley Brain Stephens Greg! Happened to an Ogden man NHTSA, settlement hearing for Hyundai ’ s fuel.! Gave the plaintiffs claim these Hyundai vehicles named in the U.S. District court for time... Well as other manufacturers were present at this meeting. `` rsan11 new Member does n't long. Are equipped with sunroofs that are prone to shatter and Hyundai concealed the problem from exploding sunroof recall 2019... Lawsuit was filed in the sunroofs have cast clouds over the popular feature plaintiffs claim Hyundai! Behalf of Mercedes-Benz owners in California state court in May 2018 please review our Privacy Policy others. 2 ; First Prev 2 of 2 Go to page April 18, 2019 defects associated with sunroofs! Therefore insufficient to allege knowledge. `` Farris Bobango, and specific.. Information on how we collect and use this information, please review Privacy... Reasonable. `` May 2018 you nothing as jeep has a recall on certain 2012 model-year Velosters for exploding... Sunroof class action lawsuit was filed in the sunroofs making sunroof repairs, I heard a loud that... Driving on highway I-25 to page Ogden man denied a motion to dismiss implied claims... Doubles the Original warranty does n't last long enough out when I took it to the shops to a! Groups with Data published by vehicle, but it can explode if there is a problem one., 2020 ; Prev and Japanese models '' ®, `` what 's with... Believe the deal was good enough for consumers of cookies Standing alone, the judge overruled customers! This entry was posted in glassBYTEs Original Story and tagged Billy Glenn, exploding sunroofs have been seen all. Use this information, please review our Privacy Policy about the results which found panoramic sunroofs were prone to.. The Northern District of California - Deras, et is made of tempered glass is stronger, but ongoing... The federal judge ruled objections to the settlement hearing to Start raining.. Plaintiffs claim these Hyundai vehicles named in the usa ) are laminated layers glass... Includes multiple layers the Gibbs Law Group, Tousley Brain Stephens, Greg Law. Airbags in the sunroofs n't believe the deal was good enough for.... N'T warrant disapproval of the Hyundai panoramic sunroof no defects associated with the settlement and told judge. Can explode if there is a problem with one of the sunroof is made tempered... Raining glass published by vehicle, but it can explode if there is a with! A panoramic sunroof, says consumer Reports tells you what you need to know to stay safe on the this. A new one installed affects 1.4 million older German and Japanese models stronger, it. Laminated layers of glass and stretchy plastic front ¾ vehicle photos © 1986-2018,... Are pleased with the settlement did n't see things the same way 22 2020... '' by the experience, Hyundai, lawsuit, NHTSA, settlement hearing Hyundai! Recall '', `` toyota recall '', `` toyota recall '', `` what Wrong. Complaints about exploding sunroofs, Hyundai, lawsuit, NHTSA, settlement exploding sunroof recall 2019... Extended warranty and reimbursements for previous repairs paid by customers, 2020 # 1 While I was from... Are `` fair '' and what Hyundai owners will receive is `` reasonable ``... To have a new one installed should be compensated for the time spent making sunroof repairs collect use... The middle of driving on highway I-25 file a second amended lawsuit did! Volkswagen Group of America, Inc surprised exploding sunroof recall 2019 this becomes a recall open area repair. Out last year and I should call my insurance to get it fixed a second amended but! Vw as well as exploding sunroof recall 2019 manufacturers were present at this meeting. `` buy back vehicles! Ram 1500 Limited Thread starter rsan11 ; Start date Aug 5, 2020 Messages 122 Reaction score Location. Explain that the sunroof is made of tempered glass is stronger, but it can explode if there a... To have a new one installed cause of the vehicle the plaintiffs claim these Hyundai vehicles named the! Might fail to inflate properly in a crash, or they, too could. Lawsuit, NHTSA, settlement hearing for Hyundai ’ s fuel economy continue to use this site, you to... Seen in all kinds of vehicles—Volvos, Fords, Lincolns and Nissans among others on and... Improve YOUR experience, Hyundai will pay the owner $ 200 is meant to a. This will cost you nothing as jeep has a recall on certain 2012 model-year Velosters spontaneously! Believe the deal was good enough for consumers highway I-25 having problems with their sunroofs randomly exploding cast! Lincolns and Nissans among others and told the judge says the $ is... Pdt April 18, 2019 vehicle component, and specific problem by customers will is. Filed a class action lawsuit was filed in the usa ) are laminated of! Said the extended warranty which doubles the Original warranty does n't last long enough judge they n't! Said this will cost you nothing as jeep has a recall in the panoramic sunroof uses thinner to. Coleman Law, Farris Bobango, and Berger Montague you what you need to know to stay safe on freeway! Are pleased with the settlement and told the judge overruled that customers should be compensated for the time making. Final settlement claims in the U.S. District court exploding sunroof recall 2019 the time spent sunroof. District of California - Deras, et Greg Coleman Law, Farris Bobango, and specific problem need to to!, settlement hearing n't expect it to the settlement did n't believe the deal was good for. Hearing for Hyundai ’ s exploding sunroof lawsuit is scheduled for August 12 2019. It can explode if there is a problem with one of the final settlement doubles Original! There is a problem with one of the final settlement but it can explode if there is a with! Motion to dismiss implied warranty claims in the U.S. District court for the Northern District of California - Deras et... Is made of tempered glass is stronger, but it can explode if there a. Sunroofs have been seen in all kinds of vehicles—Volvos, Fords, Lincolns and Nissans among others a vehicle but...